Sunday, January 29, 2012

HELP ME CHOOSE

As I mentioned in my last post earlier today, I am participating in Lori's Pink Lemonade quilt along.  I didn't have enough yellow for the alternating blocks.  I took pictures of the blocks set on top of the two choices that I have.  If neither of these works, I will go buy something else.  But, maybe one of these will be OK.  Please let me know your opinion on which of the yellow looks best - or, if you don't like either one, tell me that too.  I think I have enough of either to cut the pieces required.

A.


B.



26 comments:

Lori said...

I vote for A

Betty Lou said...

I think they both would probably work but I like the first one better. Cute little quilt.

Kigwit said...

I would choose A. B looks too sparse.

---"Love" said...

I think A looks a little softer looking, so that's my choice of the two. Whatever you decide will be just fine! ---"Love"

Marsha said...

I like the more cheddar look of B, unless that is just the lighting. I also like A, so it's your choice!

Robyn of Robyns Nest said...

A !

Marie said...

I think I like the first one better...it looks like more of a true yellow. The other seems too gold.

LuAnn said...

Either one would be fine, but I think that because A has the fine print it makes the blocks stand out more. Love your blocks!

Michelle said...

Of the two, I'd say A. I am strugeling with this right now as I am not a fan of most yellows...so I have not found the "right" color yet to finish mine.

Karen said...

I like "A". I agree that it is softer looking.

Janet O. said...

I think they both work, but "A" provides a little more visual contrast. The smaller print is a nice counterpoint to the larger graphics of the shoo-fly blocks. But maybe I have no clue as to what I am saying. : )

Christine said...

I think they both look great, don't buy use one of them love them

a good yarn said...

I'm hopeless - I can't decide! ann :-)

Alice said...

You could use both, like the original.

Kathie said...

I actually like B , its different and the flowers are just so pretty with your fabrics you chose for the blocks!
Kathie

Liriopia said...

I like them both, so I don't think it really matters. Why don't you mix it up and use a little of each?

Liri

Katie said...

Another "A" vote here! I opened your blog and had to do a double-take because I thought I'd hit Ann Hermes' instead! It looks great!

Julie in the Barn said...

I vote for A also. I think it works perfectly. No need to buy something else.

quilt32 said...

I also like A the best.
Lillian @ lillianscupboard.wordpress.com

Rebecca said...

I like version A. I think the smaller print makes the blocks more pronounced.

Linda in NC said...

I like the print of A but of B though I like the tone of B better than A. (Just muddying the waters ;-) I guess!)

Sharon said...

"A" would be my choice...isn't this a great little quilt?

quilter000 said...

Rhonda I think it is A all the way. As it is more old fashioned like the bnlocks are tyo me I love them and it will be great.
Quilter000

canuckquilter said...

I'm no help. I like them both!

Beth said...

It looks like the A fabric is the favorite. I like B a lot too, so either way it will be great.

Taryn said...

A is my favorite, too.